Free Shipping on orders over $75 (Excl. Sensory Toys)

Your cart

Your cart is empty

Continue shopping

New Plush & Toys

134 Results

Clear filters
Schylling Party Animals Guinea Pigs Mystery

Schylling Party Animals Guinea Pigs Mystery

$9.00

1 color
Schylling Pocket Pup Mystery

Schylling Pocket Pup Mystery

$9.00

1 color
Schylling Party Puppies Mystery

Schylling Party Puppies Mystery

$9.00

1 color
NeeDoh Funky Pup
Sold out

NeeDoh Funky Pup

$9.00

1 color
NeeDoh The Groovy Glob Super
Sold out

NeeDoh The Groovy Glob Super

$17.00

1 color
PeachyBbies Dino Dreams Cloud Slime

PeachyBbies Dino Dreams Cloud Slime

$17.00

1 color
PeachyBbies Strawberry Ice Cream Cloud Dough Slime

PeachyBbies Strawberry Ice Cream Cloud Dough Slime

$17.00

1 color
Taba-Licious Fluffs Fuzzy Squishy Orb

Taba-Licious Fluffs Fuzzy Squishy Orb

$8.00

Colorful alligator toys with a hand holding one, on a white background with 'Curious Minds' branding.
Colorful squishy toy held by two hands with 'Curious Minds Busy Bags' branding.

Stretchy Mochi Dragon

$6.00

1 color
Three star-shaped objects in red, blue, and pink on a white background.
Colorful star-shaped objects on a white background
Sold out

Starfish Sugar Squisy

$7.00

Packaging of Sticky Stretchy Body Parts toy with cartoon character on a white background
Collection of sticky stretchy body parts including fingers, eyeball, skull, heart, brain and ear

Sticky Stretchy Toy Body Parts Blind Bag Orb

$5.00

1 color
Slime Snackle Box with colorful slime and packaging on a white background
Sale

Slimi Snacklebox Sweets DIY Slime Kit Orb

$16.00 $12.00 25% off

1 color
Set of cute animal-themed squishies with packaging on a white background
Sunshine Surprise Pets color-changing panda toys transforming from white to purple with sun

Taba-licious Sunshine Surprise Pets Color Changers Orb

$10.00

1 color
GOAT Slimi Mega Surprise by ORB

GOAT Slimi Mega Surprise by ORB

$6.00

World's Smallest Monchhichi brown monkey figure in clear retail packaging
World's Smallest Monchhichi brown plush toy held between fingers showing miniature size

World’s Smallest Monchhichi Figure

$10.00

1 color
World's Smallest Care Bears Stretchies purple bear toy in clear retail packaging
World's Smallest Care Bears Stretchies green Good Luck Bear in clear packaging

World’s Smallest Care Bears Stretchies

$10.00

1 color
Load more