Free Shipping on orders over $75 (Excl. Sensory Toys)

Your cart

Your cart is empty

Continue shopping

New Plush & Toys

134 Results

Clear filters
Can’t Put It Down Sugar Smooshies Jumbo Ball Orb Toys
Sold out

Can’t Put It Down Sugar Smooshies Jumbo Ball Orb Toys

$7.00

1 color
Taba-Licious Fun Fruit squishy toys in assorted fruit shapes and colors

Taba-Licious Fun Fruit Squishy Orb Toys

$7.00

1 color
Douglas Gigi black poodle plush toy with curly fur and red ribbon

Gigi Black Poodle Plush Douglas

$16.00

1 color
Curious Minds Toys -Large Duck Sugar Squishy
Sold out

Curious Minds Toys -Large Duck Sugar Squishy

$10.00

Curious Minds Toys - 1 Bag of 6 Gummy Bear Squishy Mochi Fidget - Cute Animal

Curious Minds Toys - 1 Bag of 6 Gummy Bear Squishy Mochi Fidget - Cute Animal

$7.00

Colorful gummy bear-shaped toys with children's hands interacting with them on a white background
Colorful gummy candies with 'Taba Licious' packaging on a white background

Taba-licious Faves Sugar Squishy Pack – Orb

$7.00

Colorful stress balls with a hand squeezing one, on a white background
Three packages of Chupa Chups Squeeze Gumballs with pink, blue, and green gumballs on a white background.

Glow-in-the-Dark Sugar Squishy Gumdrops – Orb Toys (Mystery Color)

$7.00

1 color
NeeDoh Wild Cats Fuzz Ball
Sold out

NeeDoh Wild Cats Fuzz Ball

$8.00

5 colors
NeeDoh Nice Ice Baby Multi Pack
Sold out

NeeDoh Nice Ice Baby Multi Pack

$12.00

NeeDoh Dohnut Hole Multi Pack
Sold out

NeeDoh Dohnut Hole Multi Pack

$10.00

NeeDoh Cool Cats Multi Pack
Sold out

NeeDoh Cool Cats Multi Pack

$10.00

NeeDoh Galactic Glow Dream Drop
Sold out

NeeDoh Galactic Glow Dream Drop

$10.00

1 color
NeeDoh Squeezza Pizza
Sold out

NeeDoh Squeezza Pizza

$8.00

Toy banana with a green top and yellow bottom on a white background
Yellow banana with green tips on a white background

Easy Sqweezy Banana Stretchy Sensory Fidget Toy

$15.00

Packaging of Teeny Tiny Babies with small toy figures displayed on a white background
Hand holding a small purple figurine against a white background

Orb Teeny Tiny Babies – 40 Mini Toy Collectible Babies

$7.00

Three colorful baby dolls in packaging on a white background
Three colorful, iridescent baby dolls held in hands against a white background

Sugar Swap™ Onesie Baby Squishy – Slow Rise Squishy

$10.00

1 color
Load more